Thanks Evan for the detailed info. This is a busy week for me, but next
weekend I will be giving a more detailed look at your software and answering your mail. Cheers, Offray Ps: for some reason your post don't become part of the thread in my mailing client. They start like new post, but keeping the title. :-/ On 27/07/15 18:44, Evan Donahue wrote: > Ah, yes, by 'offline' I did mean outside of the mailing list, but that > was purely out of consideration for the list. If the list wants to > hear it, far be it from me to keep it from them. > > For my part, I am a graduate student working on my dissertation, and I > have been trying to build tools to facilitate that as I go, from > taking and sharing notes, to visualizing primary material, to > (eventually) organizing and writing the dissertation. I have been > following Offray's updates with interest, as I think my goals are very > much allied, but I am starting in a slightly different place, if I > have understood correctly (research and organizing, and not yet > writing, sharing, or publishing). My efforts thus far have been > concentrated in two repositories: > > Chancery (http://smalltalkhub.com/#!/~EvanDonahue/Chancery > <http://smalltalkhub.com/#%21/%7EEvanDonahue/Chancery>) is an early > prototype for a note taking system. I am coming from taking notes in > emacs org-mode, and so Chancery right now is the most straightforward > collapsable tree outliner/note taker that could give me functionality > basically equivalent to what I had in org-mode, and serve as a > platform to co-evolve my research methods and their supporting > technology. The near-term goals for this involve adding metadata > (authors, dates, etc) to the sources I am annotating and using that > for various kinds of historical visualization (and further, attendant > annotation) eg who wrote what when, referencing who, influenced by > what, etc), and can I edit all that directly in its graphical form. > The status of this project is that it is usable by myself and those I > have worked with on it (and I use it as my primary note taking > system), but I'm not sure what it would look like to someone loading > it at the moment (no real intro/docs, as it was just a quick prototype > to provoke further design discussion). > > Trantor (http://smalltalkhub.com/#!/~EvanDonahue/Trantor > <http://smalltalkhub.com/#%21/%7EEvanDonahue/Trantor>) is a > disttributed p2p system for incrementally keeping data structures in > sync between multiple, asynchronously connected pharo instances across > the internet without requiring human attention to resolve merge > conflicts (think laptos where data is edited offline and then > automatically synced when they connect to one another); it is my > answer to sharing and collaboration for things created in Chancery > (although it is a more general purpose project). Functionally, Trantor > provides a set of common datatypes (set, dict, text blob, etc) and a > means to run nodes and peer them for synchronization of said > datatypes. The goal with respect to Chancery/personal information > management is being able to easily grab some structured set of notes > or writing out of the note taking system and share it with > collaborators or colleagues with a button click, and without having to > go through the whole export/send/manage versions dance. This project > is about 85% complete, the proof of concept works, it just needs a big > refactor to make it usable and quash some bugs. > > I guess my observations on using Pharo thus far are first, that it is > absolutely ideal for evolving prototypes, since you get a sort of poor > man's gui and persistance (object inspector + image serialization) > basically for free, which is 90% of the work of such a simple > information management app prototype. I have a fully functional tree > outliner at a point when in another language I would still be trying > to hack a low functionality command line interface. The other thing > I've found refreshing is that my application can live as one among > many within the image, sharing data with other programs by passing > objects around in a way that is impossible to do with a standalone > application running on a modern operating system. the dream of the web > is, I think, heading more in this direction, but working with the > browser (as I was before I came to pharo) requires coordinating a > separate server process, compressing everything into http/html/json, > and a host of other problems that vanish when you can just serialize > objects between pharo instances. In short, I'm getting a lot done in > this language and I expect I'll be around for a while. > > Cheers, > Evan |
This post was updated on .
In reply to this post by Peter Uhnak
Hi
I have not developed it further - next version has to be together with the new text stuff coming up in Pharo 5. I know for sure I have no intention to do a HTML renderer in Pharo. My use case was to be able to write simple formatting as in Pillar inside the comments primarily, which is still the use case I will consider in the future. (And all the other comments was more in depth as I can actually say right now) Best, Kasper |
In reply to this post by Evan Donahue
Hi Evan, Thanks for this mail. I am really happy that you are seeing Pharo as such a productive environment. I also think the direction of Trantor is highly interesting. Cheers, Doru On Tue, Jul 28, 2015 at 1:44 AM, Evan Donahue <[hidden email]> wrote:
|
In reply to this post by Evan Donahue
Le 28/7/15 01:44, Evan Donahue a écrit : > Ah, yes, by 'offline' I did mean outside of the mailing list, but that > was purely out of consideration for the list. If the list wants to > hear it, far be it from me to keep it from them. > > For my part, I am a graduate student working on my dissertation, and I > have been trying to build tools to facilitate that as I go, from > taking and sharing notes, to visualizing primary material, to > (eventually) organizing and writing the dissertation. I have been > following Offray's updates with interest, as I think my goals are very > much allied, but I am starting in a slightly different place, if I > have understood correctly (research and organizing, and not yet > writing, sharing, or publishing). My efforts thus far have been > concentrated in two repositories: This is really great to share this with us > > Chancery (http://smalltalkhub.com/#!/~EvanDonahue/Chancery > <http://smalltalkhub.com/#%21/%7EEvanDonahue/Chancery>) is an early > prototype for a note taking system. I am coming from taking notes in > emacs org-mode, and so Chancery right now is the most straightforward > collapsable tree outliner/note taker that could give me functionality > basically equivalent to what I had in org-mode, and serve as a > platform to co-evolve my research methods and their supporting > technology. The near-term goals for this involve adding metadata > (authors, dates, etc) to the sources I am annotating and using that > for various kinds of historical visualization (and further, attendant > annotation) eg who wrote what when, referencing who, influenced by > what, etc), and can I edit all that directly in its graphical form. > The status of this project is that it is usable by myself and those I > have worked with on it (and I use it as my primary note taking > system), but I'm not sure what it would look like to someone loading > it at the moment (no real intro/docs, as it was just a quick prototype > to provoke further design discussion). > > Trantor (http://smalltalkhub.com/#!/~EvanDonahue/Trantor > <http://smalltalkhub.com/#%21/%7EEvanDonahue/Trantor>) is a > disttributed p2p system for incrementally keeping data structures in > sync between multiple, asynchronously connected pharo instances across > the internet without requiring human attention to resolve merge > conflicts (think laptos where data is edited offline and then > automatically synced when they connect to one another); it is my > answer to sharing and collaboration for things created in Chancery > (although it is a more general purpose project). Functionally, Trantor > provides a set of common datatypes (set, dict, text blob, etc) and a > means to run nodes and peer them for synchronization of said > datatypes. The goal with respect to Chancery/personal information > management is being able to easily grab some structured set of notes > or writing out of the note taking system and share it with > collaborators or colleagues with a button click, and without having to > go through the whole export/send/manage versions dance. This project > is about 85% complete, the proof of concept works, it just needs a big > refactor to make it usable and quash some bugs. working on p2p with Pharo. > > I guess my observations on using Pharo thus far are first, that it is > absolutely ideal for evolving prototypes, since you get a sort of poor > man's gui and persistance (object inspector + image serialization) > basically for free, which is 90% of the work of such a simple > information management app prototype. I have a fully functional tree > outliner at a point when in another language I would still be trying > to hack a low functionality command line interface. The other thing > I've found refreshing is that my application can live as one among > many within the image, sharing data with other programs by passing > objects around in a way that is impossible to do with a standalone > application running on a modern operating system. the dream of the web > is, I think, heading more in this direction, but working with the > browser (as I was before I came to pharo) requires coordinating a > separate server process, compressing everything into http/html/json, > and a host of other problems that vanish when you can just serialize > objects between pharo instances. In short, I'm getting a lot done in > this language and I expect I'll be around for a while. > > Cheers, > Evan |
Hi everyone,
how did things go with theses projects? It seems like the orgMode parser never was ported to Pharo 6 and later: https://github.com/JurajKubelka/OrgMode Also, was Trentor ever completed and published, Evan? I'm interested in building and using a Pharo based GTD system and would like to use OrgMode files as the database so I can still use the OrgMode ecosystem with its how-tos and mobile apps etc. And then gradually transition to Pharo. Is anyone else interested? cheers Siemen |
Hi,
Unfortunately, Trantor is currently abandoned. I didn't have a good approach to CRDTs at the time. I think it could be done better now, but I'm not working on it currently. Cheers, Evan |
Free forum by Nabble | Edit this page |